Recently on Cyclingnews.com |
 Dauphiné Libéré Photo ©: Sirotti |
Letters to Cyclingnews - August 27, 2004
|
Here's your chance to get more involved with Cyclingnews. Comments and criticism on current stories, races, coverage and anything cycling related are welcomed, even pictures if you wish. Letters should be brief (less than 300 words), with the sender clearly identified. They may be edited for space and clarity; please stick to one topic per letter. We will normally include your name and place of residence, but not your email address unless you specify in the message. Each week's best letter gets our 'letter of the week' award. We look for for letters that contain strong, well-presented opinions; humour; useful information or unusual levels of sheer helpfulness. Please email your correspondence to letters@cyclingnews.com. Recent letters Olympic road races |
|
Kudos
As bad as American television is slammed for being biased on covering American success stories during the Olympics (and thereby neglecting to cover track cycling), I read Cyclingnews daily and can't help but notice how Cyclingnews is equally guilty of bias in covering the Aussie wins at the cycling events. This is great for 2 reasons! Why? Because I realize how great the Olympics are in creating admiration and association with one's nation like few events do, and because it makes people realize how similar athletes from differing nations are and in turn, how similar people from different nations are. We have too few avenues and opportunities to view such a wide array of cultures.
I love to see the unabashed bias we have in associating with our respective nations and viewing how dramatic the effect sport can have. The Olympics binds us like few events can. It captivates us, it motivates us, and hopefully, it can better us by making us realize how much people from different nations have in common. When I watch war torn Iraqis support their soccer team, or Israelis gather to celebrate the joy of a first Windsurfing Gold medal, or the anguish Japanese gymnasts feel no differently from what an American would feel, I make a genuine association with my fellow fan and athlete. It makes me consider what else I may neglect to consider what we have in common.
Kudos to Cyclingnews on having great coverage of the Olympic events in general but in particular, for conveying the pride of Aussie success.
With that said, GO USA!
Daniel Lim
New York City, NY
Thursday, August 26, 2004
Well, yes, okay, thanks for being so reasonable about it, and we're guilty as charged - up to a point. Cyclingnews is owned by an Australian company but the staff includes Brits and Americans as well as Australians. And we defy any cycling fan not to get excited over what the Australian team achieved at Athens. Six gold medals. Six! It's a unique achievement in the history of Olympic cycling and would be worth getting excited about whoever did it. - Letters Ed
Medals
Why the discrepancy between swimming and cycling? Phelps (USA) was reported here as getting a gold as he swam in the heats. Why not then the Australian cyclists (or any other athlete who makes the team achieve a medal)?
John Andrews
Singapore
Tuesday, August 24, 2004
John Coates must go!
It must have been a bitter pill for John Coates to swallow, to present "Flyin Ryan" with his gold medal Tuesday night. Not that someone watching would have known that John Coates was Australian, from the way the medal was presented, it may as well have been thrown to Ryan. Scenes reminiscent of John Howard awarding medals to the victorious English Rugby team last year. It will be interesting to see how quickly the Australian media performs a backflip as they congratulate our most successful cycling team ever. How will John Coates explain to his corporate pals that they have missed out on the opportunity to support some of our most talented and successful athletes.
Farewell John (either one mentioned)
Ross Mackay
Sydney Australia
Wednesday, August 25, 2004
$125,000 Criterium in Charlotte
Well, it's been a few weeks since the inaugural Bank of America Invitational Criterium was held in uptown Charlotte, NC. To all who attended, myself included, it was a great success. I'm almost certain the pro riders are enjoying their cut of the $125,000 prize money. The fans, estimated at well over 30,000, seemed to have enjoyed themselves on a beautiful cool summer evening. Bank of America, the title sponsor, received considerable airtime (live TV in particular) and great press; hopefully, they will return next year with a bigger and better venue.
Still, something's not quite right. I remember, almost hauntingly, of a venomous letter I read in cyclingnews.com, August 2003. I have yet to see an apology from that writer, John Carruthers (Syracuse, NY) to race promoter Thad Fischer of Charlotte, NC.
Some of the highlights. ”I find it both tiresome and irresponsible to have yet another promoter spouting off about an event," reeks of malice and, possibly, a personal vendetta. He goes on to blast OLP Racing (Outdoor Lighting Perspectives) for assembling a "wannabe-pro squad of 40–somethings”. Really, last time I checked they had some promising espoirs, in addition to local talent, on the squad as well.
He concludes with the sardonic question, "could promoters and team managers please restrain themselves from distributing fantasy under the guise of news?"
Well, I think Albert Einstein, years ago, answered it best: "Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds."
E. Scott Dawson
Waxhaw, NC
Monday, August 23, 2004
Judith Arndt #1
If Jay Lakes really doesn't have a clue what caused Arndt's reaction he should just shut up. In fact Arndt's reaction was still pretty "relaxed" when I think about the actions by the German Cycling Federation before the Olympics:
a) Rossner was promised to have a place on the Olympic-team if she wins the German championships... she won and the president backed off because he claimed he had also promised the place to Brodtka in April after her world cup victory!
b) If Rossner would have been in the team Arndt would definitely have won gold because she wouldn't have had to lead the Aussie girl to the Finish line if Rossner, definitely one of the best sprinters in the world, had been behind in the pack. Arndt, Rossner and Worrack ride in one team all the year so they naturally would have been the best Olympic team. Arndt's reaction had nothing to do with the fact that Rossner is her friend!
c) If the German federation would have known anything about cycling and tried to build the most athletic and cohesive TEAM, like you mentioned, the team would have been Arndt, Rossner and Worrack - everybody agrees with that - except the president of the German federation.
Mario
Germany
Sunday, August 22, 2004
Judith Arndt #2
I must agree with Mr. Lakes concerning Ms. Arndt's selfish and offensive behavior at the Olympic women's road race. It is completely inappropriate for a rider, no matter how gifted, to display such base and rude behavior on the world stage. 99.9% of Olympic fans don't know what she's on about, and probably don't care. In retrospect, it's pretty clear that Ms. Arndt should have stayed home to have a good pout with her friends. Cycling needs to put heroes on the world stage, not self-important brats. I hope Ms. Arndt does not regret her career decision.
Mike Leahy
Seattle, WA USA
Friday, August 20, 2004
Judith Arndt #3
The reason 'sportsmanship' is such a big issue in athletics is that it's a struggle for high-level athletes, who tend to be obsessive, selfish and isolated; the reason everyone says politics 'should not play a part' in sports, and above all the Olympics, is an attempt to deny the fact that they are so obviously saturated with politics.
That's not the point. Arndt could be exactly correct in her assessment of the selection process, or exactly wrong, it doesn't matter. She showed more than she probably wants people to know about her, and will be remembered for it out of proportion with her accomplishments.
Be that as it may, if Arndt was obnoxiously 'childish', then the idea of 'stripping' and 'relegating' is obnoxiously paternalistic -- though it certainly is a good enough fit with the paternalism of the institutions of sport themselves, systems that are complicit in all of the vanities that these athletes suffer and benefit from.
Mark Jenkins
Portland, Oregon
Friday, August 20, 2004
Death wobbles
The wobble comes from a combination of frame flex AND front wheel shimmy. Any low spoke count wheel with spokes laced from alternating sides of the hub will pull side to side as these spokes transfer the load. This can be minimized by a stiff rim and tight spokes. It can be handled by a stiff fork/frame much better. Tires also make a difference in damping.
I recommend tensioning the spokes. Also try a different wheel just to see if it makes a difference.
Bill Shook
American Classic, USA
Friday, August 20, 2004
Pedaling furiously #1
Anybody from NorCal who has ridden into the beautiful, tree-lined, rich, snobby and notoriously anti-cyclist town that is Woodside, probably has gotten a ticket along a road there.
I have seen police following cyclists along there numerous times and I myself was given a ticket for riding 2 abreast and had to go to court. It was ridiculous. Riding in a group constituted heresy for a while there I remember.
What is funny is that Eric Heiden lived there, and Och lived with him there
for a while when moving.
Regis Chapman
Sacramento, CA
Friday, August 20, 2004
Pedaling furiously #2
In 1963, I was pulled over by a policeman while riding a 100 mile time trial who said "I've been watching you, you've been riding too fast". This was in an event which the police had sanctioned. At the time all riders were in the centre of the road overtaking slow or stationary traffic.
Tony Lewis
UK
Friday, August 20, 2004
Rewriting history
I agree that past records should be stripped from athletes. I would also like them, in cycling, stripped of any titles and that they should repay their winnings. However, these things are unlikely to happen. What would hit athletes much harder would be for sponsors to sue them for damages to their image. They have the financial clout to do it. When you look at how many companies advertise on a cyclist's shirt that number of companies suing for damages would bankrupt the offender.
Even better with this idea is that it would probably take but one case to put enough fright into all competitors to make them forget about cheating,
Norman Winn
France
Friday, August 20, 2004
IAAF getting tough?
Just found this little tidbit regarding IAAF drug testing in an AP story from the Olympics: "Under IAAF rules, athletes face sanctions in the event of three drug-test 'no-shows' in 18 months." I'm not sure how tough that is. The story went on to describe those wacky Greek athletes who had that horrible motorcycle crash that caused them to miss their tests. "Before the missed test in Athens, the Greek runners were absent when testers looked for them in Chicago on Aug. 10-11. The IAAF is also looking into a third possible case involving Kenteris in Tel Aviv, Israel, in late July."
Hm, maybe I'm wrong here but three missed tests in a couple of weeks is a little suspicious. I wonder whether the IAAF is really that tough.
Eric Lepping
USA
Thursday, August 26, 2004
Rider Wages
While almost everybody is aware that Lance Armstrong is the highest paid cyclist in the peloton, most cycling nuts I talk with have almost no idea what type of ching the other riders are pulling in. How much are the other stars of the Euro peloton making? What about the neo-pros? More interestingly, what about the U.S. D3 teams? What are the big guns making? How about the fresh-from-Cat1/2 rookies? I guess it's the low end of the spectrum that I'm really curious about. The impression I get is that they really have to scrape by in some instances. Can anyone shed some light on the subject?
Nicholas Smith
Maine, USA
Thursday, August 26, 2004
Tour de France #1
Regarding Ian Farquharson's suggestions for "improving" the Tour, they smack of the same thinking that dominated certain golf courses "Tiger-proofing" their events, only to lead to more domination by one-dimensional athletes. De-emphasizing the TT's and team tactics might help an explosive climber (assuming they don't catch mono), but that might make the flatter stages even less influential than they are now.
The Tour de France is designed to test a complete rider. Saying that recent wins have been due time trial results would ignore some epic days in the Pyrenees and Alps in the last few years. The Tour ain't exactly broke, so further tinkering isn't about to fix anything.
Matt Inzeo
Washington, DC
Friday, August 20, 2004
Tour de France #2
In responding to Ian Farquharson's suggestion to simplify the tour to make it both more interesting and more equal, he doesn't get DRACONIAN enough!
NO TEAMS! Yeah! Take away the teams and make support completely neutral. Like it was 70 years ago? No team car to water-bottle-tow them back up to the pack, nor team members. They flat, they get themselves back on, or like us in our local RR, get dropped to the bus.
NO DRUGS! Latest test for HGH, and blood exchange. All riders stabilized by race doctors at 44-46 hematocrit. No asthma med. No synthetic hemoglobin or designer steroids. Just training. Can they race without a cocktail?
NO BONUS TIME! Yeah, again! They get the time they earn. To make it as dramatic as possible, NO SAME TIME, they all have transponder, make them all work for the line! These racers making half a million Euro or more can't straggle in, they will have to get off their duffs and work.
NO ELECTRONICS! This is a bike race, boys, not an x-box. No radios, power meters, heart rate monitors, speedometers. They don't need a transmitter hanging off their butt to tell them they are out of place, out of food, and cramping. They can cobble together a race strategy in their head, and live with the consequences of their own decisions.
NO WAY! It is not going to happen, would be fun though.
J. Williams
Kern River Valley CA
Friday, August 20, 2004
Tour de France #3
1. Having no communication would not add any 'excitement'. Instead, water should be dispensed by neutral service. This would mean riders could not hold onto the team car for water bottle 'accelerations'. Also, no rider would have to fall back 10 cars to reach their team car for water. ( How can you stop the 'imaginary' brake problems like Mayo had though?)
2. The TTT may soon be dropped despite the fans feelings. A mountain TTT would be amazing though wouldn't it?
3. Cycling events need less teams not less riders per team. Having only 6 riders would limit a team too severely if one or two riders crashed out. Removing every traffic island in a race would be safer but an unlikely event. Limiting each team to only one sprinter in the final kilometer would be safer for all riders also.
4. Use electric motorcycles so athletes are not breathing carbon monoxide for 6 hours. (How about those mini-planes with a single operator. They could just hover right above the race.)
5. It would be just plain nonsense to run the ITT backwards. Everyone would watch the first ten riders. Then wait two hours for the lesser riders? What would Lance do for two hours waiting to collect his prize and jersey presentation?
Here is a good question, are there any true cyclists heading the UCI or are they all merely business men with no clue to what fans and cyclists really want?
Timothy Shame
USA
Friday, August 20, 2004
UCI Bike Weight Restrictions
There do seem to be some good intentions in the UCI's weight and design restrictions, both for safety reasons and to enable costs to stay down for lesser teams/nations/individuals, however, people manage to adapt and the prices keep rising.
I've thought for a while that the main problem with the weight and measurement restrictions is that by setting an absolute limit (6.8kg) they are assuming that all cyclists are the same size. In any given race Magnus Backstedt (over 2m tall, 100kg) can ride a bike made of feathers, and David Extebarria (less than 1m tall, 3kg) has to ride one made of lead. Similarly in TTs the regulations state that the reach of the tri-bars can only be a maximum of 10cm in front of the centre of the front hub, in this instance Magnus has to really squish himself up, and David can have a nice lie down. Some things can be got around by innovative mechanics, like chopping off the saddle nose to make sure it's still legal, but the regulations in their absoluteness penalise everyone who isn't the ideal size.
As for the ban on monocoques (non-diamond ones anyway), this hasn't quite had the effect of getting prices down. Tried to buy a Pinarello Motello recently?
Speaking of weight restrictions, did I read in l'Equipe that as Basso's prototype Cervelo was below the minimum weight, the mechanics put heavier tyres on, or is my French getting rusty? How stupid is that, the outside of the wheels is the last place you want to add weight!
Ben Atkins
UK
Friday, August 20, 2004
Mactier's reaction
Does anyone have any idea what this means, from August 24's news?
Mactier: Project LA
Beasley, who stayed in Melbourne for the Games, spoke to Mactier and said she felt "weird" about her outstanding performance.
"After talking to her, she said she had this really weird feeling: she got silver, but she lost the race, whereas you win to get bronze," Beasley said.
"Of course, on reflection, she's also happy with doing her fastest times. I told her to work on expanding her skinfolds over the next few days, then the March worlds are our next goal.
And what are skinfolds and how do you expand them?
Philip Bouscarle
Herts, UK
Tuesday, August 24, 2004
Jeff Jones replies:
Mactier lost the race against Ulmer for gold, and thus got the silver medal. But if she rode the other final (for the bronze) and won it, she would have "only" got the bronze medal. Of course you have to be quick enough in the opening rounds to get into the gold medal final. It's an odd interpretation, but I see what she means. For an athlete, the winning feeling in the final is very important - and in this case Mactier didn't get that, whereas she would have if she'd "won" the bronze medal. I guess that's why you see so many happy bronze medallists compared to silver medalists on the track.
As for skinfolds, they are a measure of body fat percentage. You expand them by eating doughnuts and drinking a lot of beer :-)
Yiddish Cycling Terms
If we are going to start using Yiddish in the cycling world, can we exchange Podium Girl for "shayna maidel?"
A shayna maidel literally translates as "a pretty girl." It describes inner beauty and is an expression of love and of yearning hope.
Ari Weinstein
Sarasota, FL
Monday, August 23, 2004
Recent letters pages
- August 20 letters - Rewriting history, Arndt should have been relegated, Crowds at the Olympic road races, Olympic road races, Racing with a concussion?, Sponsors and Olympics, Hamilton, Julich & CSC, True ambassadors of the sport, Death wobbles, There are other races, CSC tactics, Shmenges, The debate begins, Tour de France, UCI Bike Weight Restrictions, Pedaling furiously
- August 13 letters - Bush vs. Kerry, Brits at the track, Nicholas Roche, Olympics and Lance, UCI Bike Weight Restrictions, Pedaling furiously, Armstrong vs the hour, Armstrong vs Simeoni, David Millar, Greg LeMond's comments, No romance in France, The debate begins, The power of a team, The Tour 2004
- August 6 letters - John Coates must go!, Witch hunting in the 21st century, Greg LeMond's comments, Bush vs. Kerry, David Millar, Adam Bergman
- August 6 Tour letters - If you had told me before the Tour..., Looking to the future, The Tour 2004, The power of a team, The debate begins, Fan behavior, The anti-Lance attitude at Tour 2004, TdF blood bath, No romance in France, Italian investigators, I hope to see the Giro at last, CSC tactics, Armstrong vs Simeoni, Armstrong vs Klöden, A Legend
- July 30 Tour letters - The Tour 2004, The Debate Begins, Armstrong vs Simeoni, Italian investigators, Ullrich and T-Mobile, Fan behaviour, The supporting actors, The power of a team, The anti-Lance attitude at Tour 2004: A French view, TdF blood bath, TdF 2004 ITT profile, Tour Favourites, Most inspiring ride of the Tour, Postal for la Vuelta? Poor prize money, LAF Bands CSC tactics, A Legend
- July 30 letters - Adam Bergman, Greg LeMond's comments, Drugs in cycling, Doping reporting, David Millar, Museeuw and getting doored
- July 16 Tour letters - The TdF saved my life, A sad day for Hamilton, T-Mobile's choices, LAF Bands, Mario Cipollini vs. Jaan Kirsipuu, Playing by the rules of the game, Robbie McEwen and sprinters, Ullrich v. Riis, Stage 3, Stage 4 TTT, Stage 5 - 12 minutes?
- July 16 letters - Greg LeMond's comments, Drugs in cycling, Museeuw and getting doored, Human evolution and cycling, David Millar, The French affair, Why thank Lance?, Canadian TV
- July 9 letters - Drugs in cycling, David Millar, Cadel Evans, John Lieswyn, Human evolution and cycling, Museeuw and traffic, Canadian TV
- July 9 Tour letters - Stage 5 - 12 minutes?, Stage 4 - The team time trial & those rules..., Stage 3 - Should the leaders have waited?, Jan Ullrich / Lance Armstrong
- June 25 letters - Chris Horner & US Olympic Trial, The French affair, Cadel Evans, The battle for the commentary podium, Tour contenders, Will stage four decide the Tour, A thank you letter for USCF, USADA, AAA/CAS, Museeuw doored - his fault?, Beloki's allergy medication, Discovery Channel kit, Green jersey dog fight, Iban Mayo's uphill TT bike, LA Confidential, Tour-Giro double, Why thank Lance?, Searching for Bill Clawson
- June 18 letters - A thank you letter for USCF, USADA, AAA/CAS, LA Confidential, Green jersey dog fight, Iban Mayo's uphill TT bike, Museeuw doored - his fault?, Why thank Lance?, Will stage four decide the Tour?, Beloki's allergy medication, Discovery Channel kit, Does Zabel go?, Jan Ullrich / Lance Armstrong, Rochelle Gilmore, Tour-Giro double, Cycling and hip replacement
- June 11 letters - Will stage four decide the Tour?, How Ulle will win this year's TdF, Climbers' Jersey, Rochelle Gilmore, Simoni and "the impossible", Cycling among top five tested sports, Rousseau's au revoir, Jan Ullrich / Lance Armstrong, Giro, Does Zabel go?, Days of racing needed to prepare, Cunego's Giro victory, Chris Horner, Robbie McEwen, Cycling and hip replacement
- June 4 letters - Giro, Cunego's Giro victory, Damiano Cunego, Cunego in stage 18, Team tactics at the Giro, Simoni trying the impossible?, Robbie McEwen, Pavel Tonkov, Jan Ullrich, Chris Horner, Cycling among top five tested sports, Cycling and hip replacement
- May 31 letters - Au revoir Lance, Cunego's Giro victory, Pavel Tonkov, Serguei Gontchar, Dr Ferrari's Giro stage 13 analysis, When the boss has to go..., US Postal makes waves?, Robbie McEwen, US Postal stops sponsorship, US Postal sponsorship replacements, Jan Ullrich, Iban Mayo & the Tour, Tour de Georgia, Chris Horner, Orbea Orca
- May 21 letters - US Postal sponsorship replacements, Chris Horner, Fred Rodriguez - persistence pays, Donuts. Is there anything they can't do? , McEwen's sprint, US Postal stops sponsorship, Soooper Mario, Jesus Manzano, Jan Ullrich, Orbea Orca, Trying to contact John Auer
- May 14 letters - Tour de Georgia, Chris Horner, McEwen's sprint, US Postal stops sponsorship, Seating requirements, Aero Helmets, A different Wheaties box, George Hincapie, Jan Ullrich, Skip Spangenburg, Cycling and hip replacement, Afscheids Criterium Johan Museeuw, indeed, Timing, Davide Rebellin's remarkable feat, Orbea Orca
- May 7 letters - A different Wheaties box?, Afscheids Criterium Johan Museeuw, Jan Ullrich, George Hincapie, Doping and team doctors, Davide Rebellin's remarkable feat, US Postal stops sponsorship, Top 5 at TdF 2004 - not Mercado!, Two Men and a Dog, UCI Pro Tour, Cycling and hip replacement, Timing
- April 30 letters - Doping and team doctors, Davide Rebellin's remarkable feat, Spring Classics slam, Mercado - the time is now, USPS stops sponsorship, UCI Pro Tour, George Hincapie, Gilberto Simoni, Jan Ullrich, Harmonic motion, Tour de Georgia, Cycling and hip replacement, Timing
- April 23 letters - The rainbow curse, Verbruggen is the problem, Gilberto Simoni, George Hincapie, Jan Ullrich, Questions on doping, The doom of doping, Floyd the future of USPS?, Dope testing, Magnus Backstedt, Roger Hammond, Gear ratio chart
- April 16 letters - Floyd the future of USPS?, Magnus Backstedt, Jan Ullrich, David get outta there!, Cofidis and the Tour, Michelin Tubeless at Roubaix, Manzano, Vale Muur van Geraardsbergen, The Doom of doping, Hincapie, Javier Oxtoa, U.S. Excitement, Radios, Roger Hammond, England or Wales?
- April 9 letters - Vale Muur van Geraardsbergen, Manzano, The Doom of doping, Amore e Vita, Boonen, Two Speed Cycling?, A welcome end to pro cycling?, Stripes, Karma, Wesemann's setup, Roger Hammond, USPS sponsorship, Javier Oxtoa, April Fool's, UK to Geneva route?
- April 2 letters - A welcome end to pro cycling?, Manzano & doping, Finding the right team?, USPS sponsorship, WADA and Armstrong, Karma, Bjarne Riis, Is Tobias Steinhauser a real person?, Javier Oxtoa, Max number of champions in a TdF, Radios, Stripes, Chamois: real or synthetic?
- March 26 letters - A cycling fan's prayer, Manzano, USPS serendipity, UCI statement post Jesus Manzano, Jonathan Vaughters doping response, Moser comments about "updating" the MSR, WADA and Armstrong, Parsimony, Drugs, Genes, US MTB racing, Bjarne Riis, Iban Mayo, O'Grady & Milan Sanremo, The 'World' Cycling Series, Javier Oxtoa, Max number of champions in a TDF, Radios, Sean Kelly and the 1992 Milan-San Remo, We're not sprinters, Is Tobias Steinhauser a real person?, An old cycling top
- March 21 letters - Bjarne Riis, Radios, US MTB racing, WADA and Armstrong, The "World" Cycling Series, Doping, Iban Mayo, Armstrong's brakes, Fixing Cipo's problem, Max number of champions in a TDF?, Sean Kelly and the 1992 Milan-San Remo, The most fashionable men of the peloton, We're not sprinters, Jame's Diarrhea, Bobby Julich Interview
- March 12 letters - Radios, WADA and Mr Armstrong, Speculation about Genevieve, Doping, Aero helmets, Brad McGee, Chubby Lance?, How many more have to die?, Iban Mayo, Lance's Performance, Marco Pantani - who is guilty?, Rabobank and U. S. Postal, There's more to life than sprinting, Tour without Kelme?
- March 5 letters - Speculation about Genevieve, Brad McGee, Doping, How many more have to die?, Tour without Kelme?, Aero helmets, Chubby Lance?, Climbers and sprinters, Fixed gear, Mt Wallace climb, Stage 3 of di Lucca, TdF04 travel itinerary?, Tour de France 2004
- Letters Index – The complete index to every letters page on cyclingnews.com
