Tech Feature: US trade show wars continue, December 15, 2006
United States show-down
The growing popularity of the Eurobike
show
Photo ©: Messe Friedrichshafen
|
The Interbike bicycle trade show may not be to everyone's liking, but
is another major US trade show the right solution? Cyclingnews Tech Editor
James Huang looks at some of the issues surrounding the current
debate.
Just five weeks after announcing plans for a rival US trade show to be
held in Portland, Oregon, Messe Friedrichshafen, organizer of the Eurobike
show held in Germany, has decided to postpone the event to an as-yet-undetermined
date. Officially, the company has cited "delays in assembling a US management
team". However, although many industry players were clearly in support
of an event that would be more in keeping with Messe Friedrichshafen's
decidedly more pleasant European counterpart, overall opinions on the
proposed two-show format have been mixed at best.
The harsh realities
Messe Friedrichshafen's plans called for its Portland show to be held
in early September, a mere three weeks prior to Interbike, and likely
would have brought a dose of healthy rivalry to what is currently a virtual
monopoly. In fact, Interbike show group director Lance Camisasca was looking
forward to the challenge, saying, "We welcome competition, as it will
help us do a better job. However, we are also greatly concerned about
the dividing effect Eurobike's announcement may have on the industry.
Many will remember the time when the industry suffered through multiple
shows resulting in additional expense and heartache."
"We welcome competition, as it will help
us do a better job. However, we are also greatly concerned about
the dividing effect Eurobike's announcement may have on the industry."
-The thoughts of Interbike director
Lance Camisasca are shared by many
|
Indeed, the logistical hurdles this scenario would have presented to
exhibitors would have been substantial, yet the idea still enjoyed some
halfhearted support. "If there were a second show, we'd likely attend
in some capacity", said Devin Walton, PR Officer for Shimano. "The biggest
challenges would be resources as the timing, location, and requirements
for displays, products, and personnel. In the past, we've done multiple
shows over many years, attending CABDA, Interbike East and West, and even
BIO all in one year, so we've proven that it can be done logistically,
but whether or not it makes sense from a marketing and fiscal standpoint
is another issue."
Other companies that are not so fortunate to have Shimano's distinctly
vast resources, however, aren't quite so enthusiastic. According to Eric
Schutt, MTB Public Relations and Media Manager for SRAM Corporation, "If
you look at how that show fit in the global trade show calendar, we would
have had to build another booth, we would have had to have a whole separate
staff... there's no way we could have attended. The only advantage of
doing an additional show would be to give Interbike some competition and
to make them bring their game up, but another show doesn't make [the situation]
better."
Competition and logistics aside, Bill Duehring, president of Felt Bicycles,
added, "I feel no company in the US wants two shows. The shows have become
so expensive; most small to medium-sized companies would have a very difficult
time supporting two of them. Also, it's not just the expense a company
goes through. More importantly, it would be a huge drain on our employees."
Viva Las Vegas
This year's Interbike was the largest in its 25-year history with nearly
22,000 attendees on hand, roughly 370,000 square feet of total exhibition
floor space, and arguably one of the most positive vibes in recent memory.
Yet, in spite of the show's apparent success, the mere fact that Messe
Friedrichshafen's planning for the proposed Portland show had progressed
as far as it did raises some valid questions.
Curiously, industry insiders with whom we spoke were not as interested
in a second show as they were in simply having a show in a new location
for one reason or another. For sure, Interbike's current setting on the
Las Vegas strip is contentious, to say the least, and the incessantly
blinking lights, chattering machines, and general atmosphere of egregiously
conspicuous consumption have apparently taken their collective toll. "Get
out of Vegas as soon as possible!" says Duehring. "Years ago Vegas was
affordable, but now the hotels and food are too expensive, and it's too
hard on my employees after working the long days at the show. The overall
feeling that I get from my staff and dealers is everyone would like to
move."
Ironically, though, it is Interbike's relocation from Anaheim to 'Sin
City' that has had a large part in securing the show's dominant position
over the now-defunct CABDA and BIO shows. Atmosphere aside, Las Vegas
has a lot going for it as a convention setting from a practical standpoint,
including a suitably large convention center, close proximity to a majority
of exhibitors and attendees (36% come from California), mostly reasonable
airfare, plentiful accommodations, ease of transportation, and generally
centralized layout.
"Vegas Sucks. Move Interbike to Denver"... or Portland... or, um...
Messe Friedrichshafen's three CEOs:
Klaus Wellmann, Rolf Mohne and Jürgen Schmid.
Photo ©: Messe Friedrichshafen
|
Many alternatives have been proposed and championed for an alternative
location to hold an industry trade show, but the sheer size and logistical
complexity of such an event greatly limit the list of viable options.
Interbike's organizers, VNU Expositions, have long been criticized for
what is perceived to be some sort of vested interest in keeping the show
in Las Vegas, but VNU Marketing Director Rich Kelly adamantly claims that
the choice of venue is purely a pragmatic one.
Kelly himself openly admits that, "Portland is an awesome city, as are
a lot of other cities. We'd love to be able to go out and do some beautiful
scenic bike rides in a nice town if we were there, but in reality, people
there set up their booths, they're there to entertain customers, they're
there to meet with their vendors. Once that's all said and done, if there's
a little free time, then you can look at some other options. But the priority
here is to have a location where it is easy and cost effective to conduct
business at a trade show."
The more idyllic setting of Messe Friedrichshafen's proposed show in
the Pacific Northwest likely would have satisfied the current show's detractors
that have been continually calling for the event's relocation to a more
bicycle-friendly locale, but it's unclear whether or not that sort of
change in surroundings would have made the situation as a whole any better.
Even if completely sold out wall-to-wall, Portland's convention center
could house a show only one-third the size of the Sands Convention Center,
and moreover, would essentially have no room to expand. Speaking of rooms,
lodging would also be a concern as there are roughly only 4000 hotel rooms
in Portland's "metro area". In this case, "metro area" does not necessarily
equate to "downtown", nor does it imply "walking distance". To put things
in perspective, Las Vegas' Venetian hotel, which is physically connected
to the Sands Convention Center, contains over 4000 rooms on its own.
On the other hand, Denver's convention center is large enough to house
a major US bicycle trade show and has an abundance of lodging available,
but one that is scattered in a broad area. In addition, the convention
centers of both cities are not located in close proximity of their respective
airports.
The Eurobike "feel"
Eurobike's exhibition grounds in
Friedrichshafen, Germany
Photo ©: Messe Friedrichshafen
|
Having said that, industry perspectives on Messe Friedrichshafen's Eurobike
show have been quite positive overall, in spite of the fact that it is
neither easy to get to nor is it immediately surrounded by any plentiful
supply of food or lodging. Much of that perception, and the show's general
success, seem rooted in the general environment of the show's setting.
Eurobike is held in the picturesque German countryside and the physical
layout of Messe Friedrichshafen's convention center itself encourages
frequent jaunts outdoors and bathes its interior with natural lighting.
Much of the excitement with the proposed Portland show laid in the hope
that Messe Friedrichshafen would somehow be able to transfer some of that
ethos to the States, but how that would be physically possible is unclear
to say the least, particularly considering that Eurobike's halls are wholly
owned by the organizers.
Still, Scott's Adrian Montgomery perhaps puts it best in saying that,
"The only advantage [to the Portland show] would have been to encourage
the Eurobike feel." Fresh air and sunlight notwithstanding, a key element
of that Eurobike "feel" is the consumer component of the show; while the
majority of the event is only for members of the industry, the last day
of the exhibition is open to the public. Presumably, Messe Friedrichshafen's
plans for its Portland show also would have incorporated such a feature.
This idea garners some similarly lackluster industry support, but would
likely be wholeheartedly embraced by the general cycling public.
"One of the things we were lobbying for was the additional of a consumer
element to the existing trade show, not another show", said Schutt. "We
spend an extraordinary amount of time and energy to do Interbike, and
[the media] does a good job, but at the end of the day, the consumers
don't experience it firsthand. To have a consumer element would be our
goal." That being said, Schutt also adds that "I don't think Vegas is
a place for people to travel to for a consumer bicycle show, so I'm not
saying that it's an easy solution, but we weren't fond of an additional
show."
The flight's been delayed, but is still US-bound
Interbike's Outdoor Demo is among
the most popular aspects of the show,
Photo ©: James Huang
|
In light of the recent setback, Messe Friedrichshafen has just announced
new plans to enter into a strategic partnership with the Sea Otter Classic
Festival. Sea Otter has already established itself as the premier venue
for early season introductions of new product, and the new partnership
can only serve to expand that reputation. Erich Reiss, General Manager
of International Sales & Organization for Messe Friedrichshafen, was unavailable
for comment at the time of writing, but a department spokesperson revealed
that meetings had already been scheduled with the Sea Otter Classic organizers
for mid-January at which time more information would be made public.
Regardless, the company's intentions were reinforced in a recent press
release from Messe Friedrichshafen CEO Klaus Wellmann that stated, "Messe
Friedrichshafen is committed to raising its profile in the United States."
Piggybacking on to an existing, and well-established, forum such as Sea
Otter is likely to be a successful way to do so. Wellmann added, "We'd
like to harmonize the trade show with the sporting event for the spring
start of the cycling season, in order to reach manufacturers, retailers,
the media, and consumers more consistently."
While still not an 'easy' solution, Messe Friedrichshafen's new arrangement
is likely much more tenable to the industry from a logistics standpoint
and would also address the consumer aspect as the event is already open
to the public, plus it still manages to shoehorn in some of that open
air feel of Eurobike. Upon learning of the idea, SRAM's Schutt stated,
"Look at how many major bicycle brands already don't go to Interbike:
Trek, Specialized, Cannondale. You have major players that aren't attending
the normal forum in a meaningful way, so why would they go to a startup
show? There are a lot of reasons to support an existing forum like Sea
Otter. It makes a lot more sense."
Paul Kantor of Avid added, "I think that sort of bike festival/race situation
is a much better format. Personally, I don't think a trade show is a good
forum for consumers to come and see product; the aisles aren't big enough,
and we can barely move up and down. Throw in a bunch of consumers and
it'd be chaos."
By all accounts, however, Messe Friedrichshafen is still actively pursuing
the US trade show project, so the situation is still far from resolved.
In spite of of the final outcome, though, it seems that US bicycle consumers
may stand to gain the most from the battle.
Photography
For a thumbnail gallery of these images, click here
Images by
Messe Friedrichshafen
Images by
James Huang/Cyclingnews.com
|